"Put Your Hands Up, Or ... We'll SETTLE!" Not Hardly, Pilgrim.

   The Securities and Exchange Commission "enforcement chief" says settlements leave your client better off than what they could get if they went to Trial.  Edward Wyatt, "House Panel to Examine Settlements By S.E.C." p. B6, col. 1 (New York Times Nat'l ed., "Business Day" Section, Saturday, December 17, 2011), quoting "Robert Khuzami, the S.E.C.'s director of enforcement".  That is true only when you lose at Trial all the time.

   Anyone who has actually litigated cases knows that you settle when the risks to your client are greater than the chances of recovery.  No active practitioner ever consistently recommends settlements of potentially successful lawsuits because the amount of the settlements is equal to the amount or as much as your clients could get if they went to Trial.

   Evidence of this truth is clear.  Private lawsuits against "banks" return far more money than settlements negotiated by the S.E.C. and other currently staffed Federal agencies.

   What Insurance Coverages such lawsuits will trigger is even now  being litigated, along with the lawsuits themselves.  The plaintiffs are voting with their filing fees that they will be made whole faster and more efficiently by doing the recovery actions themselves, you might say: 

   If the bank settled with the investors using the same loss ratio that was applied in the Bank of America settlement [of a lawsuit filed by private investors], it would cost JPMorgan about $1.9 billion.  Still the bank would have other exposure outstanding.  JPMorgan faces about $31 billion in class-action cases, according to McCarthy Lawyer Links, a legal consulting firm.

   Elizabeth Nowicki, a professor of securities law at Tulane University and a former lawyer at the Securities and Exchange Commission, said that the efforts by investors might turn out to be the costliest and most important way that banks are held accountable for their mortgage security creations, because the push for accountability is coming from bank clients.  For instance, in the one mortgage security case the S.E.C. has brought against JPMorgan, the bank settled the allegations in June for $153.6 million.

Louise Story, "Investors Scrutinizing JPMorgan's Mortgages" p. B1, col. 6 (New York Times Nat'l ed., "Business Day" Section, Saturday, December 17, 2011).

Please Read The Disclaimer.